Network effects are such a pernicious thing. They give us the internet, but they also give us an internet full of monopolistic worse-is-better players that use network effects to stifle improvements and competition.
Sometimes the best you can manage is to be a parasite.
So I'm back on facebook ... sort of.
My strategy for facebook is to be as near to a featureless datapoint as I can. I won't post anything. I entered as bad quality information as I could get away with. I turned all privacy controls off, on the theory that this way I don't have to worry about facebook eroding privacy since everything about me on facebook is aggressively public.
By never posting anything to facebook, I am trying to fight the network effect; trying to avoid increasing the value of facebook due to me being on it.
I've adblocked the text entry field on facebook just to avoid the temptation. I want to erase the Like buttons too. Technologically, I think a good approach would be a browser plugin that does these things while extracting all available content and optionally sending it to a RECAP-type system.
I only friend people who I need to keep up with and who have little or no other internet presence. This is because I am aware that each person I friend still propels facebook's network effect a little bit; even though they'll never see any useful information from me, they will know that they are able to talk to me via facebook.
I only log into facebook once a week or so (this is easy when you're not interacting with it anyway), and read whatever sample of farmville and other posts facebook selects as "important" (worse than usual probably since I never give it feedback). So people I friend can't rely on me reading everything they do, which reduces the value a little more.
I will probably delete this account occasionally, and then re-add it later. Just often enough to be really annoying.
Similarly, I no longer gate my identi.ca account to twitter, and have deleted as many tweets as I could stand to (one click and one keypress per tweet; no mass-delete; ugh!), and protected my account to avoid accidential new tweets leaking out.
Since twitter is not quite as evil as facebook I feel slightly less bad about exposing more of my social graph there. Only the folks who are too lame to get on an OpenMicroBlogging site like identi.ca.
phone
Of course there was a network effect with the telephone as well, and while it got deregulated it's still pretty bad, and also a technology that I mostly dislike using. Oddly my phone behavior is backwards to the other two networks; I only make outgoing phone calls, never answering the phone (unless real life intervenes very severely). I listen to some random fraction of my voice mail and read whatever ones manage to get machine-transcribed.
I have no twitter, i have no facebook, i hardly blog, i don't do hyves and i hate mail, what am i?
We need 'anonymous identity' wich serves the right to privacy but can be enhanced with personal data when 'I' need it. After all doing a bank transfer is a different level of identification then buying a bread at the bakery.
We shouldnt accept the risk of our identities being stolen at badly protected networks or commercial entities and risk identity theft, after all it's 'my' identity and i have only one.
If you could find a way to get an RSS feed out of facebook of the few people who only post there (like our father...), I would be thrilled! I tend to log in only every week or two to check up on those folks, and like you, I think I still miss the important stuff in the flood of nothingness. Of course, I'm not as technical as you, so the reason I hate facebook is much simpler --- it seems to dumb down everyone's intelligence by at least 50 points.
--- Anna
what are you feelings about signing up for Diaspora in regards to making a 'basic' profile or using it fully as it is striving to be privacy-focused there is a FLOSS CLI tool to aceess facebook(but it requires adding a FB 'app') if you want that option. Its not perfect but it may be useful enough
I have no twitter, no facebook and no other social 2.0 webshit. And you know what? I don't feel like signing up for any of this nonsense.
I really don't understand why anybody should want this. I can meet my friends at a bar and they can tell me the details of their personal life that they feel like sharing over a coffee. For those I can't meet easily because they are abroad, I have an e-mail account where they can reach me, and they have an e-mail account where I can reach them so we can be mutually updated on our respective lifes from time to time. Those that I don't feel like calling, e-mailing, or meeting at a bar, why would I want to have them on a facebook account or twitter?
"My strategy for facebook is to be as near to a featureless datapoint as I can"
I hope that's not your real date of birth, then. :(
Joey Hess: what are yoy trying to accomplish with your
parasitary
membership ? In my opinion it does not matter at all if you give your fellow users any information in your profile. Being a menber and regularly using that service in itself adds value to FB. There is a network effect anyway if you make friends with other users. And if the use of your membership is only that they have someone they can put on a terrorist-blacklist. Behaving that way is a declaration of war. If you don`t like that service you really should leave it all alone and have all of your data deleted when you leave.